Hunter vs Muck Boots: Which Is Better?

These boots are some of the few great go-to guys when you want to get the best of your stay in the countryside, go hiking, or probably go on any type of forest tour.

“Hunter Vs Muck Boots”  has become a popular contrast and comparison when needs like this arise.

While both are great in themselves, there are some features in the respective design of varying models of each brand that will, in some cases, meet the demand, and in other cases, not meet the needs of people.

The main difference between Hunter Vs Muck boots is that a hunter boot is made of natural rubber, it runs a little large, has a glossy finish, is moderately comfortable, and has a fabric lining that is antibacterial.

Muck boot on the other hand, although made of neoprene natural rubber too, is true to size, not glossy, and offers dual-density comfort.

Both boots are waterproof.

Being a boot freak who has used quite a number of them for over 25 years now, I understood this well enough. And as such, I have decided to sum up, largely, the different iterations of Muck and Hunter boots.

This is so that you can decide what best fits your need from a place of good enough knowledge.

What Does The First Glance Say About Hunter and Muck Boots?

I have always maintained that that first glance at not just shoes, but at any product, goes a long way to turning a potential buyer into an actual one.

I’ve on a few occasions bought terrible shoes because of their outer appeal. While it is true that looks aren’t the right metric to judge shoes, it’s cool to have good-looking ones.

Hunter Boots

At a first glance, hunter boots are eye-catching and glossy. They look soft, yet with a touch of sophistication. The blend of sturdy and comfort is captured in the design.

It comes with this aura of sleekness and dominance. You’d notice the rugged sole that tells of good balance.

Muck Boots

While it is true that muck boots are not glossy, they have more of a mature design. Most of its soles are “toothed”, and you’d notice the toe area to be slightly slanted upward and a tad curved arch. Muck boots mostly come in darker hues.

Hunter vs Muck Boots: Comparison

Features Hunter Boots Muck Boots
Material Hunter boots are made with natural rubber. It is high-level Vulcanized. The material is water-resistant. Muck boots are also made with natural rubber, albeit with a blend of CR Flex foam. Muck boots’ material makes them water-resistant too.
Sole The sole of Hunter boots are pretty tough and have good balance. They are toothed, strong and RUgged. The sole is not very light but comfortable to carry. The sole of this boot is made with aerated neoprene rubber which makes it extremely lightweight. It is toothed as well.
Durability Hunter boots are very durable. Especially as regards its wear and tear resistance. They survive the worst of situations that can easily break other boots. The durability of Muck boots beats that of most random boots. Trust the blend of CR Flex foam to deliver quality. Although compared to Hunter boots, Muck doesn’t stand a chance.
Size/Fitting Hunter boots are not often true to size. Most times people are advised to size down by half. Muck boots are true to size and almost have a snug fit. They stick to the feet well enough.
Fashion Quality The fashion quality of Hunter boots is world-class. They have a very attractive and eye-catching outer appearance. When it comes to the aesthetic appeal between Hunter Vs Muck boots, Hunter boots take the lead. Muck boots are moderately fashioned. They mostly come in darker colors. There is more comfort here than a beautiful appearance.

Hunter vs Muck Boots: Material

While there are other determining factors, materials are largely the determinant of durability, traction, and other times, comfortability.

For this reason, some materials have undergone a series of processing before they’re obtained. Hence, different material qualities differ.

The material used for making Muck Boots is the famous quality neoprene natural rubber. Muck boots, although made with natural rubber, also contain CR flex-foam which is self-insulating – it regulates temperature by itself.

The blend of these materials makes the boot cushy and more well built. Relative to most boots, Muck boots are better, however, their strength does not equal that of hunter boots.

Original hunter boots are made with good quality vulcanized natural rubber. It has good elasticity over varying ranges of temperatures.

The processing involved to obtain this material makes it have high abrasion and swelling resistance, and a far more superior tensile strength.

Hunter boots have been known to be the go-to guy for most of the “dirty” jobs because of the rare quality it possesses. If you want to go for strength, then this is home.

Hunter vs Muck Boots: Sole

The sole is the soul of a shoe. Yeah, you read that right. How best do you describe the part of a shoe that is faced with the worst of situations? This is why good shoemakers often use the best of their materials for sole construction

Muck boots are made of neoprene natural rubber, the sole specifically is made of aerated neoprene rubber.

Aeration simply translates to “being filled with air/oxygen”, this is so that it is not very heavy, however, this aeration is done at a very much controlled level to maintain quality.

I love how these things are balanced without compromising on each. You’d love the dual-density comfort the sole gives.

The sturdiness of the sole of hunter boots dates back to 1856, safe to say it is a patented design. It is rigid and rugged and relatively denser.

This sole design comes with a good balance that enhances every footstrike as it has a secure tread.

Although the calves are pretty narrow, then again, the toe area is just a little wide, so this creates a balance. Other times, this makes them run large.

Hunter vs Muck Boots: Durability

What would you say about the durability of a brand that has been making quality designs right from way back to the extent it was commissioned to make boots for soldiers during the first and second world Wars? Now you know.

Trust the vulcanized rubber used for making hunter boots to be very durable. Boots from this material resist abrasion and possess better tensile strength. This is why it can be used for strength-demanding tasks.

Muck boots are durable too. Their durability is traceable to the blend of natural rubber and CR Flex foam. They’re great and very comfortable, albeit not very sturdy.

The chemistry behind the making of this material, which improves its durability, is the reaction of isocyanates and polyols. This way, they are comfortable, yet, twice as durable as an average boot.

Hunter vs Muck Boots: Sizing/Fit

Acknowledgedly, good features, and durability speak volumes of the quality that every shoe exudes, however, sizing and fitting plays a great role in determining users’ experiences.

This here isn’t an unproven assertion, it is a fact culminated from the takes of many shoe users over the years that have largely agreed on this to be true.

Muck boots are true to size and pretty comfortable.

Most boots of the Muck brand have dual-density comfort – they have an almost-snug fitting and stay glued to the feet, hence you can run with them easily because they cling to the feet.

Although some people have reported having sized down during purchase and were cool with the fitting, then, this is not large so one is more likely to get an uncomfortable snug fit.

Hunter boots run large in size. So you are advised to size down when making any purchase; more advisable to go down by half.

Then again, you may want to go down by a whole number if you are having small feet. They are comfortable too. But then, not as comfortable as Muck boots. The hunter boots are more geared to ruggedness and sturdiness than comfortability.

Hunter vs Muck Boots: Fashion Quality

The fashion quality of Hunter boots is top-notch! They almost literally scream out your name at a first glance. Pretty glossy.

They have mostly brighter colors as opposed to Muck boots with darker hues. Hunter boots take their fashion from not just color, but also to designs and down to the sole.

Some of the models have the “Hunter” inscription atop the shaft. They come in many colors and offer a wider range of options to pick from. They are far more fashionable than Muck boots.

Most of the models of Muck boots come in darker hues. Although they’ve got a good fashion quality, while at that, they maintain moderation.

It’s obvious they come with class and decency. It all boils down to individual choice. If asked to choose, as regards fashion quality, quite a number of people will go for Muck. Not everyone wants the attention that glossy boots come with.

Why Choose Hunter Boots?

Choose Hunter boot if your regular place of using a boot is one that needs a stronger boot; Hunter boot is the ideal choice for sturdiness.

Boots of this brand are very strong and reliable – they can withstand the toughest of times and come out almost untouched.

This is because of their abrasion resistance and good tensile strength. If you have large feet, you should choose Muck Boots as they run large to accommodate your feet. They are very resistant to slippery grounds too.

Are you a fashion freak?

Choose Hunter boots for good fashion quality.

Why Choose Muck Boots?

Choose Muck boots for high-level comfort that takes true foot care into consideration. They are very soft, tender, and light.

What accounts for this is the aeration that the material passes through. Choose Muck boot as an alternative that can find relevance in snowy weather.

Hunter vs Muck Boots: Disadvantages

Muck boots

  • Not all countries can ship them.
  • Unavailability in half sizes.
  • Muck boots are not very durable.

Hunter Boots

  • They are a tad still and limit normal for wiggles and movements.
  • Hunter boots are not very great in snowy weather.
  • The runner can suction your feet if you wear them without socks.

Overall Quality

For overall quality, Hunter boots take the lead. The density of the material, the resistance to abrasion, the tensile strength; ability to not easily give in to wearing out or tearing.

It is just superb. Plus, it leads in fashion quality too, although it has moderate comfort, still, that is enough to get whatever job done.


Firstly, you must understand that the term “best” is relative. While the best boot is named so based on popular demand and how it has met users’ needs and has a good track record, that may not exactly be the best for you as there are certain unique demands that are required of a boot to fit your feet type that isn’t present there.

It is very pivotal that choices should always come from a place of good enough knowledge, as such, it is only cool that from the wealth of experience and research, we can create an ecosystem that equips people with the information to make these choices rightly.


Leave a Comment