Magnanni vs Allen Edmonds: Which Is Better?

The major difference between Magnanni and Allen Edmonds shoes is that Magnanni offers more casual and sporty shoes while Allen Edmonds is more traditional dressy.

When placed side by side, the major differences between the Spanish and American shoe brand (Respectively) lies in the leather and welt quality, visual appeal, prices, and other miscellaneous like polish absorption.

The argument on which shoe is better between Magnanni and Allen Edmonds may never end because their unique features appeal to different people with different perceptions about what makes a great dress shoe.

This article will constructively place both brands side by side across various qualities to see which does it better and is worth your money.

Why the need for this comparison?

Shoe brands are not created equal. Some brands are known for their quality, while others are known for their style.

Comparison of shoe brands like these is not new, and most times, arguments about them can be endless.

However, there are many reasons why we should compare shoe brands before buying. It is not enough to look at the design and the price of a shoe.

Many aspects need to be considered before making a purchase decision. For example, some supposedly luxury shoes might be more durable than others or have better soles.

Magnanni and Allen Edmonds shoes have a lot in common, but they also have some key differences.

For example, many enthusiasts believe that Magnanni shoes are more affordable than Allen Edmonds shoes.

Still, they don’t come with the same quality of craftsmanship and materials as Allen Edmonds shoes do.

How are we able to be sure of this before buying? Now, Magnanni shoes and Allen Edmonds shoes are two of the best shoe brands for men.

They have a very similar price point, but they differ in quality, style, and comfort.

What are Magnanni shoes’ pros and cons?

Magnanni is a Spanish shoe brand that has been around for more than half a century. They are known for their classic designs, high quality, and great comfort. This is not to say that they are without a few downsides.

Anyone buying Megnanni shoes should be aware of the following pros and cons:


  • They are very comfortable (like walking on clouds) and look great with any outfit
  • Availability of different styles to suit a wider appeal
  • Their shoes are high quality and last long
  • Their shoes are not too expensive, but they still have a high quality
  • The designs are timeless, which means they will never go out of style. This makes them worth the investment because you can wear them for years to come.
  • A fancier look than AEs


  • They are not as comfortable as other brands that have enhanced padding from the insole
  • Limited color range
  • They have a relatively low score point on durability on most online shopping platforms like Amazon.
  • Not ideal for those who resent too narrow and pointed shoes

What are Allen Edmonds’ pros and cons?

On the other hand, Allen Edmonds is an American company that specializes in high-quality men’s footwear, including dress shoes and casual footwear for both men and women.

Anyone buying AE shoes should be aware of the following pros and cons:


  • The welt quality of Alden Edmonds shoes is more solid just like in these Strand Oxford design
  • Deals better with the nasty weather
  • The visual appearance of Alden Edmonds is shorter and thicker, which appeals to most dressing moods – substantial.
  • Absorbs polish very well, either full or corrected grain


  • The price point is also higher than many other brands, which can be a downside for some people.
  • Usually unreliable fit. It requires more to get true to size for the preferred snug fit, especially online shopping.

What similarities do both brands share?

Magnanni and Allen Edmonds are two of the most popular brands in the world of men’s shoes. While they have some differences that make them uniquely appealing, both shoes share some features in their designs.

One of the most noticeable similarities between Magnanni and Allen Edmonds shoes is that they are made from high-quality leather.

In this light, there is no huge difference in the manufacturing process and sourcing of leather between both brands.

However, The leather of Allen Edmonds shoes is a bit stiffer than the one on Magnanni shoes. 

Another common design feature on their shoes is the laser detailing and stitching accents throughout.

Also, both brands are known for their quality construction that have a strong presence in the male shoe market with contemporary designs from dress shoes to casual shoes, boots, and loafers.

Both brands are also in the production line of Lace-Ups, Monk Straps, Boots, Sneakers, Loafers, Sandals, and Slippers.

Magnanni vs Allen Edmonds: Comparison

Comparing similar shoe brands to amount to which is better is not as easy as it seems.

To get a clearer picture of which should be placed above the other across all preferences, we will look at how each of the shoe brands measures up in areas of Overall quality, Material used, Soles, Durability, Price, Insoles, and Sizing.

Overall Quality

The quality of these types of shoes is determined by the quality of the leather, the design, and the durability.

Magnani shoes are made from high-quality leather and are designed with comfort in mind. Allen Edmonds shoes also use high-quality leather and have a long history of being a leader in shoe design.

This makes it hard to draw the line between both brands regarding quality, as they wouldn’t have made it a top choice for men if they weren’t of impeccable quality.

However, if we are to measure overall quality from the aspect of design, Allen Edmonds shoes are more traditional than Megnanni’s. And, shoes with a more traditional feel have the perception of being more quality than modern classics.

If quality is a priority, you should feel safe buying your next shoe from any of the two brands.


Magnanni shoes are made of calfskin leather. Allen Edmonds shoes use different types of leather, including calfskin, full-grain, and Oxford, depending on the model.

Some people prefer Magnanni because it is softer and more comfortable than Allen Edmonds, but others like the durability of Allen Edmonds shoes better.

We have a wider variety of leather types when shopping for Allen Edmonds shoes than Magnani’s.


The classic dress shoes made by Allen Edmonds usually feature single leather soles for a sleek, lower profile.

But, some of their casual shoe designs use double leather soles that give them a heftier, substantial look.

Another interesting thing about Allen Edmonds shoes is that their soles have been treated with butyl, making the leather more flexible.

On the other hand, Magnanni shoe soles are designed with special leather materials that are great for protection against wear and tear.

But some of their sneaker-like shoes, like Bravo and Sona, are made with rubber soles with impressive shock absorption.


Magnanni shoes are made of full-grain leather exemplified in their Pablo designs, and the leather is carefully tanned and dyed to give it a rich color.

Magnanni shoes are hand-sewn with waxed thread, which is stronger than other thread types because it has a natural gum coating that resists water.

Magnanni shoes have steel shanks for support and stability. They also have rubber soles that provide traction on any surface.

Allen Edmonds shoes have a thick sole that will last for years and years, but this is only due to the quality of their rubber soles. Allen Edmonds has many different styles of shoes.

The Magnanni shoe construction details are much better than Allen Edmonds shoes in durability.


The price of Magnanni shoes is more expensive than Allen Edmonds shoes, even though they are within the same price bracket.

If you are looking for an affordable pair of quality shoes, then Allen Edmonds is the best choice.

The average cost of Allen Edmonds shoes is $390 at retail price, while Magnanni is around $450 upwards. (you can see some designs below $400, though)

Meanwhile, It is not always true that the more expensive the shoe, the better it is.

I have realized that, even when shopping with a budget, price should be the last thing on your priority list when conflicted between two brands like Magnanni and Allen Edmonds.


Magnanni shoes are designed with a European last, which means they are not as wide as American lasts. This can make Magnanni shoes feel snugger than other types of shoes.

Allen Edmonds shoes come in various widths and sizes to accommodate different foot shapes and sizes.

A good way to know if your shoe is the right fit is to have about ½ inch of wiggle room at the end of your longest toe when you stand up.

Fewer people have problems with fitting and sizing after buying AEs than those who purchase Magnanni.

Who should buy Magnanni shoes vs Who should buy Allen Edmonds?

Magnanni shoes are known for their style and their quality. They are an investment, but they will last longer than cheaper brands.

If you want to buy Magnanni shoes, think about what you’re looking for in a shoe and how much you’re willing to spend.

The company offers classic styles with a modern twist, so it appeals to so many people from all walks of life.

It is also one of the most expensive shoe brands today, so it may not be the best choice if you’re searching for something more affordable.

On the other hand, Allen Edmonds is a brand that offers high-quality products for the mid-to upper-middle class.

When compared with Magnanni, the shoes are considered an affordable luxury, but they last a long time and are worth the investment.

Allen Edmonds shoes are perfect for people who want to look nice and have something stylish but not too flashy.

So which is better? – Final remark

Allen Edmonds and Magnanni are both well-known for their high-quality shoes. They offer a wide variety of shoes for different occasions and styles.

All things being considered, none of these shoes will disappoint across the common features and specifications.

However, I strongly believe it would be a better decision if you opted for Allen Edmonds shoes.

There is a high rate of encountering Magnani designs that are not as reliable as advertised. But rare is the case for AEs.


Leave a Comment