Grenson vs Allen Edmonds: Which Is Better?

Grenson vs Allen Edmonds is a common internet comparison that you can find every day as people try to understand which is better.

Other times you see people do this when they are torn between making a shoe choice when they want to make a purchase.

This article will serve as an easy guide and will give you a side-by-side comparison, and an easy-to-understand explanation so you can make your choice from a place of better understanding.

Here is what you must know;

Grendon shoes are designed with tanned calfskin Italian leather. They are true to size and have a standard fitting.

The soles of these shoes have a double leather design. They are nice and comfortable; a perfect hybrid of luxury and class.

Although their soles are not big on traction control and can be a bit slippery when used on wet ground. 

Meanwhile, Allen Edmonds shoes are designed with shell cordovan leather which is a vegetable-tanned leather that is subjected to oil treatment during the tanning process.

They run half a size large, they are made with leather soles that are dense and thick with a good dose of water resistance and anti-slip properties.

What does the first glance say about Grenson and Allen Edmonds shoes?

Every customer is always met with the first glance of a product before there is a chance to know more about it.

Aesthetics plays a great role in determining the probability of picking a product. We shall see how well Grenson and Allen Edmonds have done in this regard.

Allen Edmond Shoes

Allen Edmonds is quite shiny. You’d recognize this at a first glance. The shoe has a Goodyear welt construction. It comes with a form and rigid leather sole and lace eyelets.

There is a good chance of picking Allen Edmonds in a host of other shoes. The aesthetic of the shoe is appealing.

Grenson Shoes

Grenson Shoes are classic and stylish. They are made of waxed calf leather. You’d notice the smoothness at a first glance.

The shoes have Goodyear welted double leather soles with the brand’s name boldly written underneath them. They are quite attractive and catchy to the eyes.

Let’s see more information about these shoes

  • Leather
  • Sole
  • Durability
  • Insole
  • Price
  • Size/Fit
  • Fashion Quality
  • Overall Quality

1. Leather

Shoe materials are to a very large extent, the core determining factors of the flexibility, foot-friendliness, and durability of shoes.

Aside from maintenance also is a factor, the material used for every shoe’s design influences how long it’d last. This is the reason many manufacturers subject their materials to many processes.

Grenson Shoes

The material for Grenson shoes’ designs is fine Italian calfskin leather. They have good appeal and are to a very good extent, comforting and flexible.

This leather type is breathable for air permissibility such that it keeps the foot not too dry and not too moist. Grenson never disappoints. I have been using one for more than 8 years now.

Allen Edmonds Shoes

Allen Edmonds shoes are made with durable Cordovan leather (See on Amazon). They are vegetable-tanned leather and offer better foot gain.

The oil treatment they undergo during their tanning process increases their wear resistance such that they are not prone to damage with ease.

When many brands take certain measures to boost their durability, Allen Edmonds is never left behind.

2. Sole

Shoe soles face more hurdles than any part of a shoe component. Soles get to directly face different terrains; whether in harsh conditions or at easy times.

It is important that extremely durable materials are used for the construction of soles. It is a good thing that these shoes did well in this area.

Grenson Shoes

Grenson shoes’ soles are made of leather. For a fact, they have a double leather design for increased toughness to withstand difficult times.

The welt finely connects it with the uppers such that it is not easily misaligned and wears off. Grenson soles are indeed durable and are always on the go.

Allen Edmond shoes

The sole of Allen Edmond is made with strong leather. It is wittingly constructed to be thick and dense just so there is better resistance to slip and good ground control.

The original property of this leather is graced with some synthetic polymeric materials for improved performance and bounciness to keep you on the go.

3. Durability

To what end is the functionality of the components of a shoe if the shoe itself doesn’t last?

This is why it is of paramount importance that shoes are designed with durable materials and with the right construction to make them less susceptible to wearing and tearing.

See how Grenson Vs Allen Edmonds shoes are doing regarding this.

Allen Edmonds

Allen Edmond has an enviable depth of durability that cuts far beyond shallow quality. All thanks to the construction and adopted material for the design.

The long-lasting leather insole contributes to this too. The first encounter I had with this brand was with a friend in college years back.

He used it almost every day for three years, and when I asked, “Allen Edmonds” was the name. Since then, the name stuck and I have never forgotten it.

Grenson Shoes

Meanwhile, Grenson shoe shoes are durable too, although not as durable as Allen Edmonds. Grenson Shoes carries a demonstration of the practical reality of how shoes can carry both fineness and quality.

This is one shoe that conquers different territories. Be sure to cheer up with the result you will get here, especially if you are big on fashion.

4. Insole

The insole of every shoe must be predominantly defined and made of quality and comfortable material. The sound effect and presence of the influence of a good shoe insole are always felt during use.

Good insoles are the primary determinants of comfort. Why so? Because they have direct contact with the foot.

Grenson Shoes

Grenson Shoes have good insoles that comfort and therapeutic feeling submits to. Grenson has succeeded in creating an imprint of relief and soothing feeling that has long materialized in the world of footwear.

The Grenson insoles have a double leather design – comfortable and nice. I have seen many people that are advocates of Grenson Shoes’ insoles.

Allen Edmonds

Allen Edmonds insoles on the other hand are comfortable too, albeit not as comfortable as the insoles of Grenson Shoes.

Allen Edmonds insoles are made of leather with a healthy extent of density and thickness such that does not keep the feet in stiff positions but are comfortable enough to have your feet on the go.

5. Price

The price of every shoe is mostly influenced by the materials used for the design, the construction strategy adopted, the processes of the materials are subjected for improved durability and customer satisfaction, and customers’ demand.

All of these affect the pricing of products.

Grenson Shoes

Grenson Shoes sell within the price range of $305, $350 to $450, depending on the model.

I love how manufacturers have recently broadened the varieties of their designs and models these days and have attached a due price to them so that there is a wide options range for customers according to their preferences.

And the Grenson shoe brand has done great with this too. You can check them out on their official website or Amazon.

Allen Edmonds

Allen Edmonds shoes usually cost within the range of $350 to $395. They are durable shoes and truly worth their prices.

Allen Edmonds is one of the few shoe brands that has done well in striking a good balance between quality and price.

There are various iterations and the respective prices that are attached to them. Each with a price according to the depth of quality it carries.

6. Size/Fit

Allen Edmonds

Allen Edmonds is not predominantly true to size. There are some models of the shoe brand that run half a size large.

This is why you must study the size chart on their website so that you can get the one that best fits you.

They have a comfortable fitting and are very nice when you wear them. They have a good ground feel and better balance.

Grenson Shoes

Grenson Shoes are true to size and fit pretty well. Understand that size variations could be very tricky too.

You should align your country’s size pattern with that of Grenson to know if it syncs well. However, Grenson Shoes has better fittings than Allen Edmonds.

This is not to downplay the fitting of Allen Edmonds, this is just on the ground of relative comparison.

7. Fashion Quality

Grenson shoes have a better fashion quality than Allen Edmonds shoes. Grenson is glossier, has more fancy construction, and is more fashion inclined than Allen Edmonds.

I have seen shoes that cannot withstand the fashion appeal of Allen. But here, Grenson takes the lead. I love Grenson too, there’s hardly a person who wouldn’t want that touch of beauty.

Overall Quality of Grenson and Allen Edmonds

There are no two ways about this. Allen Edmonds wins for overall quality. Allen does not wear out with ease and can withstand harsh conditions better.

If you’re a more fashion inclined person, you may want to consider Grenson as it has the needed appeal. But durability-wise, Allen is the ideal choice.


Leave a Comment