5 Best Replacement Insoles for Sperrys

I can vividly remember when the insoles of one of my favorite pairs of Sperry’s started to dry out and roll inwards.

The worst part of the deterioration was that it included both the leather and the foam material. It cost me more time and money to eventually come across something great as a replacement to the insoles – (pedag Leather Insoles, of course)

If you find yourself in the same shoes, you really do not have to go through a tough search before coming across a solid solution.

There are many options for you out there. While some are ideal, others will just add more discomfort when used on Sperrys. You might be spoilt with choices, but don’t know how to go about it? Not to worry.

This post is for you.

Having done extensive research on what makes the actual Sperry insoles stand out, I have been able to compare and gather the best replacement insoles for casual boat shoes.

List of the best replacement insoles for Sperrys

Suppose you are in a hurry because time is money. In that case, the table below will better help you navigate quickly around the list of the most recommended replacement insoles for Sperrys.

Pedag Handmade Leather Orthotic Inserts Overall best replacement option
10 Seconds Cushion Insoles For great foot temperature
Pedag Handmade Leather Orthotic Inserts Versatile for even other shoes (athletic)
Orthaheel Relief Orthotics Best for Sperry loafers
Pedag Washable Summer Insole For those who don’t love socks
Shoeslulu Absorbent Leather Insoles  Ultra-thin design to perfectly replace your current insert

Taking pride as one of the best boat shoes one can buy to upgrade one’s summer footwear, and maintaining its prestige as a king in the boat shoe market, Sperrys 360-degree lace-up design has been paired with jeans by many fans – more attributed to the hype it got from the campaign with John Legend.

Many Sperry wearers do rip off the inserts completely when they turn bad and then replace them with an ideal insole.

Trying any of these Inserts for Sperry shoes will surely serve as an excellent way to get the support you need, especially for many outdoor activities.

If you are still in doubt, let’s run through the features of these insoles and how they measure up to the actual Sperry shoe inserts, as well as what people who have tried out the insole are saying about it.

10 Seconds Cushion Insoles

Best Replacement Insoles for Sperrys

This is one of the insoles many would want to turn to if they prioritize great foot temperature as they spend hours on their feet.

For those who rock Sperry shoe designs on a daily basis and are ready to rip out completely the initial insole for a better replacement, then this 10 Seconds Cushion Insoles is definitely worth attention.

While the product has not been able to record impressive review in writing as against similar brands with flooding written reviews, 10 Seconds insoles have a considerable number of position ratings in major online shopping stores which speaks well of its performance and longevity.

It is a good thing that this shoe provides a more comfortable fit in any shoe or boot, and not just Sperry designs, which makes it more versatile than even the number #1 recommendation.

Another useful aspect of having this 10-second insole is that it has been designed to repel odors that are brought about by the gathering of sweat from under feet after long hours of wearing a shoe.

This insole is able to dissolve that and ensure better underneath breathability to get rid of the unwanted shoe and foot smells. That’s awesome.


  • Fight odors
  • Durable foam material
  • Versatile
  • Lasts long


  • Less written reviews to firmly verify performance to an inexperienced buyer

Pedag Handmade Leather Orthotic Inserts

Best Replacement Insoles for Sperrys

Considered as the overall best replacement option for Sperrys in this extensive buying guide, this Pedag HOLIDAY is a classic 3/4 length orthotic insole.

The primary offering of this insole is to ensure arch support, plantar vault support, and provide Heel Cushion, coupled with the metatarsal pad.

Being one of the top-rated replacement insoles for Sperry shoe designs, the Pedag insole features a metatarsal pad that helps reduce symptoms of metatarsalgia and Morton’s Neuroma.

It is what you can rely on to prevent those worrying leg fatigue that is experienced after a long time of standing or walking.

Having gained laurel as the American Podiatric Medical Association (APMA) Seal of Acceptance for promoting foot health, this insole design is known for its quality and natural materials, comfort, and innovation.

On the sizing, there are close to zero reports on complaints as these insoles have been designed to fit shoes from the US sizes Women’s 5 through Men’s 15 (EU 35 – 48).

If you are going to pick this option, which I fully recommend, you want to make sure it is one that closely tallies with your shoe.


  • German Handmade Leather
  • Orthotic Inserts
  • Arch Support
  • Metatarsal Pad and Heel Cushion
  • Ideal for even Tight Dress Shoes
  • Skin-friendly


  • No faults detected so far

Orthaheel Relief Orthotics

Best Replacement Insoles for Sperrys

Among all the replacement insole options that will be shared in this extensive buying guide, these Orthaheel Relief Orthotics full-length insoles appear to be the only specified product to perfectly suit only a particular Sperry shoe design which is the Sperry loafers.

In other words, if you use Sperry loafers and looking to have the original insoles replaced, then you know better than to ignore these Orthaheel Relief Orthotics insoles.

The same recommendation goes for similar shoe brands like Sperry loafers or ones that share similar shoe structures and features.

Why? This particular insole features a deep heel cup and arch support that has been put in place to realign your feet to a natural position and prevent the foot from rolling inward

Thanks to the shock-absorbing pads that have been defined in the heel and forefoot area. In synergy, these two support systems bring nothing but Cushion to your stride.


  • Can be worn in hiking boots, work shoes, athletic shoes, and casual shoes
  • Approved by the American Podiatric Medical Association


  • No fault detected so far

Pedag Washable Summer Insole

Best Replacement Insoles for Sperrys

As long as Sperry shoe insoles and replacement is concerned, the insoles made by Pedag remain a staple consideration because their features meet the very spheres of recommendation.

To be more precise, these particular Pedag summer insoles are ideal for those who do not love to wear socks on their Sperry shoe because the insoles are very breathable and of course washable.

I believe the unique selling pull of this insole is the fact that it is a Sockless insole. What this means is that, since it is made of pure cotton terry with padded latex, users of this insole will enjoy ultimate comfort without having to wear socks.

To this effect, and in order to keep up with this task, the insole has been designed to absorb sweat so that your feet are kept. Additionally, the insole is lightweight and thin enough to fit into any tight shoes.

Thanks to the grooved and perforated natural latex padding and the fact that it can be hand washed using just mild soap and water.

For those hot months when you’ll be wearing your Sperry shoe, you can bank on these breathable full-length insoles, thanks to the cotton terrycloth that absorbs sweat.


  • Sockless insoles
  • Handmade in Germany
  • Hand washable
  • Promotes air circulation
  • Lightweight and thin
  • Absorbs sweat


  • Won’t categorically recommend shoes with little room in terms of fit and shape.
  • Will damage if tumble dry

Shoeslulu Absorbent Leather Insoles

Best Replacement Insoles for Sperrys

Lastly on this exclusive list of the best replacement insoles for Sperrys shoe is this wonderful Shoeslulu Magic Absorbent Ultra Thin Lambskin Leather Insoles that equally feature the Breathable Activated Carbon Bottom.

It is best picked for its Ultra-thin design that will allow for a perfect replacement to your current inserts

You don’t have to feel uncomfortable each time you need to take off your shoe in front of your friends or family. With the right insole just like these Shoeslulu Absorbent Leather Insoles, even your sweat will no longer have a hand in any unpleasant situation.

Thanks to the handcrafted high-quality lambskin leather that ensures comfort and moisture absorption as well as the perforated and padded to keep your feet dry and comfortable in those Sperry pairs.


  • Relatively affordable
  • Ultra-thin feature
  • Breathable material
  • Comes with a sizing recommendation


  • Just a few average complaints on the insole coming out whenever the shoe is taken off

How to know it’s the right time to replace inserts in your Sperrys

Those who use their Sperry shoes every day, and for quite intensive activities, might need to replace their insoles with new ones every 3 to 4 months.

This also applies to many similar shoe brands out there because, while insoles play a huge role in offering support to the feet, it doesn’t last beyond 6 months (on average).

There are certain signs that can be easily noticed which will clearly point at the fact that your Sperry insole is deteriorating – many of the signs are rather based on the appearance and performance of the insoles.

Your Sperry shoes need insole replacement if the inserts have issues with any of the following:

  • Unpleasant odor
  • Compression
  • Decolouration
  • Damage

What do I mean by these?

Unpleasant odor

This sign usually happens to those who spend more time on their feet. When your Sperry shoes, particularly the insoles, begin to emit a stench of disagreeable smells, it could be that there is bacteria or fungus, which can lead to foot infections.

For this case, I recommend you consider new insoles that are designed with antimicrobial fabric which prevents bacteria, mold, and mildew from residing in the fibers of your insoles.


If you are intentional about taking care of your insoles, it is likely you won’t see any obvious sign of deterioration that will call for an urgent insert replacement.

But, over time, the foam will lose its spring and you’ll realize the insoles are flatter than they used to be. That’s a sign you need a new one to ensure the right support.


From wearing off of the logo on the inserts to changes in the general appearance of the inserts, signs that reflect a contrast in the initial appearance of when you bought the insoles could indicate that it’s time for a new pair of insoles.


Finally, the main observable change that calls for a new pair of insoles is damage. Damage in the sense of tearing or cracking on any part of the insole.

Beware that at this stage, you risk experiencing blisters on your feet bcause the damaged insoles no longer offer the needed support and cushioning in the proper foot areas.

Final words

All and above, when insoles in your Sperrys appear to be compressed, it indicates a critical time to have them replaced.

However, it is one thing to know when to replace your inserts, and it is another to know the right new inserts to choose from.

With the options presented above, you should be able to make the best choice for you without any worry about disappointments.

Most importantly, as you use these new inserts, keep in mind that it might take a while for you to get used to using them, especially if you’ve been managing the previously damaged insoles for a long time.


Leave a Comment