10 Best Alden Loafer Alternatives (in 2022)

Alden is a brand that has been around since 1884, and they have a lot of loyal fans.

But Alden shoes are not for everyone. They are expensive, which is why so many people have been looking for an Alden alternative that offers the same quality but at a lower price point.

Aside from affordability, you’d also want other alternative designs to Alden Loafers because you don’t want to be ‘boring’. Variety, they say, is the spice of life.

S,o, in this article, we will explore the best alternatives to Alden Loafers shoes available for purchase online and in-store.

Top 10 alternatives for Alden loafer

  1. Temeshu Leather Formal Penny Loafers
  2. Rockport Classic Penny Loafer
  3. Mephisto Cap Vert Slip-On
  4. Martens Loafer Slip-On
  5. Cole Haan Slip-On Loafer
  6. ECCO Men’s Queenstown Penny Loafer
  7. Allen Edmonds Cavanaugh Penny Loafer
  8. STACY ADAMS Penny Loafer
  9. RICHWANAZ Tasseled Leather Loafers
  10. Nunn Bush Men’s Noah Penny Loafer

It is popular opinion that Alden shoes are expensive and not accessible to the masses. This may explain why Alden’s competitors, such as Allen Edmonds and Rockport, have started to take over the market share from Alden.

To get the best alternatives to Alden loafers shoes, a good place I started from is looking at their competitors, and here are my findings on these brilliant substitutes:

Temeshu Leather Formal Penny Loafers

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

Emerging as my top favorite alternative for Alden loafers shoes is this Temeshu Men’s Leather Formal Penny Loafers that features a handcraft upper made of Genuine Leather.

Like every Alden loafer shoe, it is equipped with an anti-slip Rubber Sole. But to add, the classic penny shoes loafers are soft and comfortable. I love the simple, easy slip-on access design that makes the pair comfortable to wear.

It appears to be better than a selected production line of Alden in the area of slip resistance and shock protection of the ankle.

Aside from that, the insole and lining are made of soft leather, which prevents feet from feeling pain and keeps them dry and relaxed always.


  • Impressive quality
  • Great buy for its price
  • Relatively comfortable for dressier shoes


  • Run a little big

Rockport Men’s Classic Penny Loafer

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

The heel of the average Alden Loafer shoe measures 3/4 inch, and so does this Men’s Classic Penny Loafer from the iconic Rockport brand.

The footwear features a leather upper with penny loafer strap detail that is very easy to maintain.

I love the removable sponge cushioned footbed that forms to your foot for added comfort.

Like many celebrated Alden loafers production lines, this one also has a comfort system designed to provide lightweight shock absorption.

The footwear is a good choice to pair with a suit for the office or khakis for dinner with friends.

I have seen a detail of polyurethane outsole in some Alden models, which is replicated in this Rockport pair to help reduce foot fatigue, and an EVA footbed for a more personalized fit.


  • Comfort of cushioning
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • The price is right
  • Ideal office gift


  • Not a good choice if you prioritize extreme arch support
  • Not flexible like many Alden shoes

Mephisto Men’s Cap Vert Slip-On

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

Mephisto is arguably among the competitors of Alden as far as Loafers shoes are involved; they make some of the finest walking shoes with a great reputation in the area of comfort, support, and durability.

The Cap-Vert is good-looking and made with high-quality materials, and will serve as a befitting replacement for any Alden Loafer design.

Aside from the front of the shoe being a little narrow, this pair is a great choice if you prioritize comfort with or without wearing socks.

If you prefer a traditional penny loafer that is better built than American brands, the german iteration of the penny loafer is a good shot.


  • Reliable leather quality
  • Comfortable with or without socks
  • Encourages breathability
  • Ideal casual design
  • It will not cost much to care for


  • It has a pretty narrow front

Dr. Martens Adrian Tassle Loafer

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

The Doc Marten’s signature shoe bottom part makes this design especially lovable. Like most Alden loafers, this pair is suitable to wear with something dressy and still casual enough for everyday use.

If you know Docs, then you will agree that they are generally rough on your feet until you break them in.

This Unisex-Adult Adrian Tassle Loafer is not an exception. However, they look awesome and have enough attitude to stand out.

Meanwhile, observe that the shoe is so high on the instep, and there are no elastic gussets.

So, if you make a slightly wrong decision in sizing, it won’t be an easy job to put them on at first.


  • Elegant design
  • Sturdy and durable
  • Great for those with narrow feet
  • They perfectly fit without socks, but nicely with socks


  • Quite heavy and hard (accounts for an advantage too)
  • Not great for an especially wide feet
  • No elastic gussets for ease in putting on and taking off

Cole Haan Men’s Pinch Penny Loafer

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

This Pinch Penny Slip-On Loafer from popular Cole Haan might not measure up with the real Alden loafers across all viewpoints, but it is an interesting alternative.

The footwear features a smooth burnished calfskin upper designed with penny slot detailing for an appealing polished look.

It does a good job of softness, thanks to the padded fully leather sock lining, making it comfortable enough to wear without socks.

The classic Suede buffed outsole is not removable, but it sure adds to the cushioned comfort, coupled with the injected thermoplastic urethane (TPU) pod.

If you are looking for an Alden loafer substitute with a low stacked heel for stability, this Cole Haan Men’s Pinch Penny Slip-On Loafer featuring the brand’s legendary Pinch moccasin last is a winner.


  • Moccasin-toe penny loafer with stacked heel
  • Perforated footbed for cushioning
  • A sturdy heel guarantees longevity


  • Not ideal for a slippery surface
  • Strictly formal

ECCO Men’s Queenstown Penny Loafer

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

Alden loafers are not the only shoe brand ideal for summer, and there are many pairs out there to prove this point. One of them is this interesting ECCO Men’s Queenstown Penny Loafer.

It is completely handcrafted and appears to be built with attention to detail. I particularly go attracted to the moc-toe stitching. It effortlessly adds to the sophistication of the leather, giving it a casual edge.

Made with a synthetic sole, the ECCO Men’s Queenstown Penny Loafer Dress Oxford is crafted from smooth, full-grain leather and designed with a fully lined interior of rich leather for softness.

The leather-covered insole is removable and replaceable to guarantee a customizable fit and added comfort.


  • Removable and replaceable insole
  • Very versatile as it can be worn casually or with a suit.
  • True to size
  • Well priced
  • Available in Navy and dark clay suede


  • It runs narrow compared to other men’s Ecco shoes
  • It will cost a little more for maintenance to retain the radiant look

Allen Edmonds Men’s Cavanaugh Penny Loafer

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

This is a classic penny loafer coming into the room as a sure replacement for all Alden loafer shoes with stacked heels and moccasin toe.

It is loved for its beautiful calfskin leather. This Cavanaugh penny loafer is built on Allen Edmonds legendary original 360 Goodyear Bench Welt.

It is no news that Allen Edmonds is in the same league as Alden in shoe manufacturing, and this design is a rival to most Alden loafers as it equally provides stability and lasting comfort.

Another thing that makes these Allen Edmonds shoes so unique is the wide range of sizing options that allow for easier picking for the perfect fit.


  • A quality shoe with a comfortable footbed
  • You can easily prolong the quality if you use Allen Edmonds walnut shoe paste
  • A relatively short break-in period


  • Arch support is not satisfactory
  • The hue is a little yellowish in contrast to what is displayed in the image

STACY ADAMS Penny Loafer

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

If you are a lover of beautiful leather and sleek silhouette, this Men’s Pierce Moe-Toe Slip-on Penny Loafer from the beloved Stacy Adams might pique your interest as an alternative or replacement to expensive Alden loafer designs.

The chiseled toe of the pierce will never go unnoticed, but the real thing about this shoe is the braided loops and the metallic ornament that makes it stand out in the room.

It is versatile for any collection and will go well with both suits and any outfit idea involving jeans.

As for comfort, the footwear is equipped with a fully cushioned memory foam insole for superior padded cushy comfort, which also doubles as shock absorption, coupled with the leather lining for decent breathability.


  • Remarkable durability
  • Stand out in the area of breathability
  • Fully cushioned memory foam insole for superior comfort
  • The metal ornament makes it stand out aesthetically

RICHWANAZ Men’s Tasseled Leather Loafers

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

If the braided loops and the metallic ornament in Stacy Adams loafer above do not win, then the dangling tassels attached to the top of this elegant brown Tassel loafer will do it.

The footwear has a flat and elegant design that is suitable for more seasoned gentlemen.

It is equipped with a full-grain leather upper and leather lining that encourages breathability by reducing the heat and the moisture. I like the footwear’s traction tread pattern on the solid rubber outsole.

As with many Alden loafers, this one works well for formal and casual. Also, the vamp is longer, so it extends out and covers more of your foot.


  • Versatile
  • Appealing design with the dangling tassels
  • Anti-slip

Nunn Bush Penny Loafer

Best Alden Loafer Alternatives

Lastly, the list of recommended alternatives for Alden Loafer ends with this Nunn Bush Men’s Noah Penny Loafer.

It is interestingly designed with classic moccasin toe detailing that grants it an effortlessly polished look for jeans, chinos, and suits.

Made with premium leather uppers, Nunn Bush Men’s Noah Penny Loafer features a fully padded sock lining with comfort Gel for outstanding comfort.


  • No break-in period
  • It can also be worn sockless
  • Very good for dancing – not slippery


  • Not ideal for everyday heavy use

How to choose which Alden Loafer alternative fits your feet?

Many people have switched to a loafer instead of going with the Alden classic because they don’t like how they look.

However, different loafers are available, and it can be hard to know which ones will fit your feet better.

Here are the three important tips you shouldn’t ignore when finding an alternative that will work.

  1. Make sure your loafers will not be too heavy or uncomfortable. You can ensure this by examining the specification of the shoe’s weight and material used in making the sole of the Loafer footwear.
  2. Find out what material is used in the shoe and its type of closure e.g presence of gusset elastic at the sides. This can help you decide whether you need something with a lot of flexibility or one that’s more durable and less likely to break down over time.
  3. Choose shoes that match your style and preference for each day so you can feel comfortable wearing them all day long without any complaints from you or anyone else in your office.

It’s a wrap

An Alden Loafer is a one-of-a-kind collector’s item made for the well-to-do. It is something that every man in the nineteenth century would have wanted.

While it remains a commodity prize among vintage enthusiasts, the footwear design has now become an expensive footwear option.

Fortunately, we have gone through some of the best alternatives to Alden loafers design in the market today that still offer equal or more quality, durability, and functional utility.

Meanwhile, you must consider what activities you will be doing and the style that will match them to choose your next pair of loafers.

If you are a person who is always on the go and needs a pair of loafers that can keep up with your lifestyle, then I’m afraid none of these shoes will work well for you – What you will need is a sneaker-style of loafers.


Leave a Comment